Questions Worth Asking Before Giving Tuesday
Everyone who funds and runs workforce and education work is trying hard, in their own lane. A job-seeker doesn’t see the lanes. They experience one path, and right now, nobody is responsible for making sure that path connects.
For four weeks this fall, The WebStudy Foundation put one question at a time on LinkedIn: some to funders, some to the educators and employers who do this work together.
Week 1: Name the problem
The jobs exist. The workers exist. What keeps them from connecting?
Which gap do you see, or run into, most often in your region?
Naming the gap you hit most is the first step to seeing the whole.
Week 2: Meeting is not the same as aligning
Funders: what’s the last convening you funded that changed what anyone did the next day?
Educators and employers: when was the last time a meeting left everyone in the room with the same conclusion?
If everyone leaves with a different conclusion, the meeting shared information but did not create alignment.
How often do the programs you fund and the jobs your region needs point in different directions? Where do you see training and hiring aimed at different targets?
Both sides can work hard and still aim at different targets.
Who decides what comes first in a region’s workforce system?
Without agreement, every partner sets its own order and the effort spreads thin.
Week 3: Time, money and evidence
Where is a one-year grant, or short-term funding, being asked to solve a ten-year workforce problem?
Funders: how many of your grantees are chasing the same gap with a different definition of success? Educators and employers: when did you last compare notes on what your region is hiring for?
Grantees who define success differently can’t add up their results.
In one state, a statewide community college network and two campuses of the same university system each got separate federal grants the same year for advanced manufacturing, construction and AI training, and we found no public plan connecting them.
This fall, The WebStudy Foundation reviewed public materials from 31 funders that already invest beyond traditional grants: program-related investments, loans, guarantees, recoverable grants, pooled funds, and outcomes-based funding. We chose them because they use these tools, so we won’t call it a trend. But we found no public evidence that any of the 31 pays out its own grants based on agreed results. Where results-tied money exists, it runs through intermediaries. That gap is an opportunity.
When a workforce grant stalls, is it the program, or that no one agreed on what came first?
Sometimes the fix is agreeing on what comes first rather than replacing the program.
Educators: how often do your completers land jobs in the field they trained for? Employers: before a local program was built, did anyone ask what your open jobs require?
Training is now judged by who gets hired. States receiving Workforce Pell funding may be at risk of losing eligibility if 70% of program completers are not employed in their trained field (U.S. Department of Education, May 2026; Federal Register). Educators and employers need the same answer to what a good result looks like.
Week 4: The same picture, first
What would your grants achieve, or your region do differently, if everyone who trains and hires saw the same picture first?
What to do with these questions
Bring two or three of these questions to your next partner meeting. Where the answers differ, your efforts disconnect.
The WebStudy Foundation is a woman-led 501(c)(3) nonprofit (EIN 30-1015810) that helps colleges, employers, and funders in a region agree on what they are working toward, before the money is spent. These groups often do good work in parallel without seeing what the others are doing. The foundation brings them together to see where their efforts don’t line up, agree on the results that matter most, and commit to what they will do together. Its process, called CapacityWorks℠, keeps the programs and partnerships a region already has and helps them point in the same direction.
See our approach.
Giving Tuesday is Dec. 1
Giving Tuesday is a national day of generosity that follows Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Our campaign, “Agree on the Results That Matter, Before the Money Has Been Spent,” pays for the facilitated work that gets a region’s colleges, employers, workforce and economic development partners, and funders to agree on shared results before money is spent. Our goal is to fund 3 to 6 regional coalitions. Regions and coalitions are candidates who could receive support, subject to fundraising and selection.
Which of these questions is your region asking? Write to [email protected] or call 888-326-4058. Donate on Giving Tuesday, and follow us on LinkedIn.
Think Together. Act Together. Align Today. Deliver Tomorrow.